mighty fine trivia by James Callan

Tag: stumpers

A lesson from Jeopardy!

As I mentioned on Seattlest, I passed the in-person Jeopardy! audition in Seattle a couple of weeks ago. Now I officially have about a 1 in 6 chance of appearing on the show in the next couple of years. I’m coming out ahead regardless — I won a Jeopardy! home game when bwouns from the Ken Jennings Message Board misremembered what year the show came back on the air.

One thing the Jeopardy! people said that stuck with me: The people on the show want you to win money. They’re not there as your adversary — your fellow contestants are your adversaries.

When I started writing quizzes, I had to learn that. In my first few quizzes, I deliberately included questions that I knew would be difficult, possibly even stumpers. At least one per round, sometimes two.

Why? I had in the back of my head that I was competing with the players. Somehow it was points for me if I stumped them.

It took reading some other people’s advice on writing questions — particularly Jennings in Brainiac, and the guys at the Trivia Hall of Fame.

Turns out it’s a lot more fun to host when you try to write questions that a lot of people can answer. I definitely still try to challenge players — a great question rewards lateral thinking. But stumping them isn’t that hard to do, and it’s not much fun when you’re on a team with a half-empty answer sheet.

I’m not there to beat the players. I’m there to give teams a good playing field where they can compete with each other.

What makes this a stumper?

The total land area of Japan is closest to the total land area of which state: California, Michigan, Montana, or Oregon?

Correct answer: Montana.

Out of 22 teams, though, none got it right. Four teams guessed Oregon, eight guessed California, and ten guessed Michigan.

I wanted to make it tricky, of course, but I never want to shut teams out. (Honestly!) If every team were randomly guessing, five or six should’ve gotten it.

My theory: California and Montana get lumped together as “big states,” and California seems like a likelier match for Japan. If nothing else, it’s similarly vertical. Michigan is the smallest state of the four, so attracts the people who want to lowball the answer.

But if anyone else wants to shed some psychological insight, I’m all ears.

© 2024 Quiz Quiz Bang Bang

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑